Back to Discussion Summary Page
Discussion Title: Lets put some supercars on a track. handling comparison
| youngvr4 |
2005-05-25 01:45:00 |
Lets put some supercars on a track. handling comparison
i have a reason for posting this(though you wont know until later). we all know its been asked which supercar is the fastest and best and wich would you have.
but which is the better handler?
with just these cars alone
Zonda c12 s 7.3
Mclaren F1
Enzo
Carrera Gt
koenigseggs ccr
put them in your own of what you think would win in a really twisty road coarse
__________________ 
The best kill in a coupe award goes to young vr4.
the coolest import car goes to young vr4.
|
| christophv |
2005-05-25 06:39:00 |
|
I think the Enzo would be the best one on the track. The CCR might have more power and the F1 might be faster on a straight lane, but the Enzo is basically a Formula 1 car with street license, both curve and parts-wise.
My vote to the Enzo, though I don't like the car generally.
__________________ 
First and current car - '82 Mercedes-Benz W123 240D - 2.4l Diesel | 97 ft.lbs. @ 2400 rpm | 72hp for 3900lbs of weight
"If Nissan Motorsports is NISMO, is Honda Motorsports then HOMO?"
|
| mason_RsX |
2005-05-25 08:14:00 |
|
I would have to say the Mcalren F1 for the same reason that Christov said then enzo, because its basically an F1 car put on the street, so its made to maximize all aspects of driving, not just top speed...
__________________ No car, just College in Halifax... Don't pretend you know where that is
|
| illegal_eagle187 |
2005-05-25 09:09:00 |
Re: Lets put some supercars on a track. handling comparison
yeah i believe the Enzo in the twisties followed closely by the carerra gt, but in the straight the mclaren f1
__________________
|
| crayzayjay |
2005-05-25 11:41:00 |
Re: Lets put some supercars on a track. handling comparison
The CGT is rumoured to have the edge over the Enzo on tight circuits, but i've seen tests where the Porsche won and tests where the Ferrari won.
I think it would definitely be between those two, though the Zonda is extremely nimble as well.
__________________
This is not 'Nam, this is AF. There are rules.
|
| 9eleventb0 |
2005-05-25 12:25:00 |
|
My vote would go to the enzo. The F1, though an amazing car, still doesn't have the same handling feel and nimbleness that the enzo has from what I've heard (its definitely close though). The carrera gt is probably the closest competition to the enzo in terms of handling, but I haven't really seen enough track comparisons between the two to tell for sure which is better.
I would really like to see an enzo timed around nurburgring.....
|
| youngvr4 |
2005-05-25 13:37:00 |
Re: Lets put some supercars on a track. handling comparison
ok, this is the reason i posted this
if we were to measure handling by pure slalom skidpad and braking
this is what the order would be
koenigseggs ccr: skidpad 1.30 braking 99ft
carrera gt: braking 101ft slalom 73.2
enzo: skidpad 1.05 braking 109ft slalom 71.0
Zonda c12 s 7.3: skidpad 98.g braking 116ft slalom 69.3
mclaren f1: skidpad 86.g braking 127ft slalom 64.5
shall we judge by these tests?
according to these numbers a transam can handle better than a mclaren
__________________ 
The best kill in a coupe award goes to young vr4.
the coolest import car goes to young vr4.
|
| crayzayjay |
2005-05-25 17:21:00 |
Re: Lets put some supercars on a track. handling comparison
Quote: Originally Posted by 9eleventb0 I would really like to see an enzo timed around nurburgring.....
I don't think the Enzo would beat the 7.32 record set by the CGT. Two reasons:
1) the CGT was extensively tested at the 'ring
2) the Enzo is more suited to smooth tracks, and supposedly bottoms out at the Karussel & other notoriously bumpy parts of the 'ring
__________________
This is not 'Nam, this is AF. There are rules.
|
| clawhammer |
2005-05-25 17:32:00 |
Re: Re: Lets put some supercars on a track. handling comparison
Quote: Originally Posted by youngvr4 ok, this is the reason i posted this
if we were to measure handling by pure slalom skidpad and braking
this is what the order would be
koenigseggs ccr: skidpad 1.30 braking 99ft
carrera gt: braking 101ft slalom 73.2
enzo: skidpad 1.05 braking 109ft slalom 71.0
Zonda c12 s 7.3: skidpad 98.g braking 116ft slalom 69.3
mclaren f1: skidpad 86.g braking 127ft slalom 64.5
shall we judge by these tests?
according to these numbers a transam can handle better than a mclaren
Does the koenigseggs ccr come with slicks from the factory, or is that a mistake? I'm guessing it's the second, probably is 1.03, not 1.3
__________________ Natural Aspirations Crew Member # 6
|
| christophv |
2005-05-26 06:10:00 |
|
nope, 1.3 is correct
http://www.koenigsegg.se/thecars/index.asp?submenu=4
look at those numbers. "ooh shit that's fast!"
But I haven't seen any tracktest like Enzo vs CCR vs CGT, would be interesting, especially on such a difficult track like the Nürburgring.
__________________ 
First and current car - '82 Mercedes-Benz W123 240D - 2.4l Diesel | 97 ft.lbs. @ 2400 rpm | 72hp for 3900lbs of weight
"If Nissan Motorsports is NISMO, is Honda Motorsports then HOMO?"
|
| peter i |
2005-05-26 07:56:00 |
Re: Lets put some supercars on a track. handling comparison
I choose Carrera Gt
I like suggest a Track too !Nurburgring
this track combine high speed & slow speed conner
easy to see the limit of a car
__________________ Love street mod & Super GT cars ? Click the ((tachometer)) to check it out!!!
|
| kfoote |
2005-05-26 09:20:00 |
Re: Lets put some supercars on a track. handling comparison
The Nurburgring is too high speed for the comparison we're talking about here.
Also be aware that the McLaren's numbers are artificially low because it uses 10+ year old tire technology. If the cars are totally stock, with stock tires, and using the Hungaroring as a good example of a tight road course, I'd put them as follows:
Carrera GT
Enzo
Koenigseggs ccr
The above 3 would be fairly close
McLaren F1
Zonda
If you put them all on the same type of tire with stock sizes, I would put them as
McLaren F1
Carrera GT
Enzo
Koenigseggs ccr
Zonda
The more high speed corners the track has, the more likely the Enzo will be to pass the Carrera GT as long as the track is relatively smooth (think Spa, A-1 Ring, or Monza)
__________________ 2004 Subaru Impreza WRX STI (daily driver)
1999 Mazda Miata (track car)
1987 Porsche 944 (being rebuilt)
|
| youngvr4 |
2005-05-27 17:59:00 |
Re: Lets put some supercars on a track. handling comparison
a 86g in 1999 is still crap
the corvette was pullling in a 91 or 92 i beleive
in 1997
you would think that a supercar like the mclaren would have better tires than a corvette ya know.
seems kinda wierd to me
__________________ 
The best kill in a coupe award goes to young vr4.
the coolest import car goes to young vr4.
|
| drunken monkey |
2005-05-27 20:15:00 |
Re: Lets put some supercars on a track. handling comparison
hmm, i wonder which car would be fastest around, lets say.... fiorano?
|
| DinanM3_S2 |
2005-05-27 22:20:00 |
|
Didn't CAR Magazine compare the McLaren to the CGT and say that the F1 had better handling?
I bet that either that 86g figure is from the 93' when the F1 came out, or is complete crap.
__________________ 
///M Power
2002 E46 M3
Carbon Black
SMG
Full Dinan S2 Package
CSL Spoiler & Rear Diffuser
Diamond Black BBS RGR 18x8.5 Wheels
I am in the process of making a BMW 3-Series FAQ thread and any suggestions would be welcome. Just send me a PM.
|
|